Reviews
Sort by:
-
Variety (Todd McCarthy)
review
- The New York Times (A.O. Scott) review
-
ReelViews (James Berardinelli)
review
-
Entertainment Weekly (Owen Gleiberman)
review
- Chicago Sun-Times (Roger Ebert) review
- Chicago Reader (J.R. Jones) review
- Empire Magazine [UK] review
- Washington Post (Ann Hornaday) review
-
Spirituality & Practice (Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat)
review
-
DVDBeaver
dvd review [Blu-Ray Version]
-
Reeling Reviews (Robin and Laura Clifford)
review
-
The Flick Filosopher (MaryAnn Johanson)
review
- James Bowman review
-
Mr. Cranky Rates the Movies
review
- Comingsoon.net review
- Lee's Movie Info (Craig Younkin) review
- Truthdig (Sheerly Avni) review
- Pajiba (Ted Boynton) review
- DVD Town (Dean Winkelspecht) dvd review [Blu-Ray Version]
- Film Freak Central review
- The Wall Street Journal (Joe Morgenstern) review
- JackassCritics.com ("Rosie") dvd review
- FilmJerk.com (Brian Orndorf) review
- In Review (Adam Suraf) review
- Wolf Entertainment Guide (William Wolf) review
- DVDActive (Gabriel Powers) dvd review
- CineScene.com (Chris Knipp) review
- CineScene.com (Howard Schumann) review
- CineScene.com (Les Phillips) review
- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette review
- Arctic Shores Contemporary Reviews (Bob Miller) review
- Screen It! Entertainment Reviews for Parents evaluation
- DVD MovieGuide dvd review
- JoBlo's Movie Emporium (Chris Bumbray) review
- Ozus' World Movie Reviews (Dennis Schwartz) review
- Film Ireland review
- Film School Rejects (Josh Radde) review
- ShowBIZ Data review
- n:zone dvd review [Blu-Ray Version]
- UpcomingDiscs.com (David Annandale) dvd review
- Box Office Prophets review
- Mediasearch, Australia review
- CineFile : il Cinema in Rete (Pietro Salvatori) review
- San Diego Metropolitan (Jean Lowerison) review
-
Reel Film Reviews (David Nusair)
capsule review
- The Critical Critics review
-
Eye for Film ("Chris")
review
-
Eye for Film (Sarah Artt)
review
- rec.arts.movies.reviews (Wick) review
- rec.arts.movies.reviews (Mark R. Leeper) review
- rec.arts.movies.reviews (Scott Mendelson) review
- musicOMH (Emma Dibdin) review
- PopMatters (Cynthia Fuchs) review
- MovieWeb (Dodd Alley) review
- Urban Cinefile dvd review
- The Independent (Anthony Quinn) review
- critic.de (Michael Kienzl) review
- The Stop Button (Andrew Wickliffe) review
- Deseret News, Salt Lake City review
- movies.com (Dave White) review
- Susan Granger review
- www.filmrecensiepagina.nl (Wilko de Bruin) review
- Christian Spotlight on the Movies review
-
filmsgraded.com (Brian Koller)
review
-
Reel Geezers (Lorenzo Semple and Marcia Nasatir)
review
- The New Yorker (David Denby) review
-
Hollywood.com (Pete Hammond)
review
- DVD Talk (Ian Jane) dvd review [Blu-Ray Version]
- DVD Talk (Phil Bacharach) dvd review
- The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel (Duane Dudek) review
- Chico News & Review (Juan-Carlos Selznick) capsule review
- Sacramento News & Review (Jonathan Kiefer) review
- Reno News & Review (Bob Grimm) review
- Chico News & Review (Juan-Carlos Selznick) review
- Philadelphia Daily News (Gary Thompson) review
- Philadelphia Inquirer (Carrie Rickey) review
- Ruthless Reviews (Matt Cale) review
- Gone with the Twins (Massie Twins) review
- Empire Magazine [UK] dvd review
- Florida Times-Union (Matt Soergel) review
- Filmtracks (Christian Clemmensen) soundtrack review [score]
- Paste Magazine (Robert Davis) review
- dvdfuture.com (R. L. Shaffer) dvd review [Blu-Ray Version]
- The Cultural Post (Anh Khoi Do) review
- eFilmCritic.com (Rob Gonsalves) review
- eFilmCritic.com (Erik Childress) review
- eFilmCritic.com (Peter Sobczynski) review
- eFilmCritic.com (David Cornelius) review
- San Francisco Chronicle (Mick LaSalle) review
- Movie Mom (Nell Minow) review
- Boston Herald (James Verniere) review
- USA TODAY (Claudia Puig) review
- World Socialist Web Site (Joanne Laurier) review
- Frank's Reel Reviews dvd review
- homevideo.about.com (Ivana Redwine) recommendation
- The Land of Eric (Eric D. Snider) review
- Row Three (Marina Antunes) review
- kids-in-mind evaluation [8.6.6]
- Film.com (Cole Haddon) review
- Plugged In evaluation
- Slant Magazine review
- Cinopsis review
- Toronto Star (Peter Howell) review
- The Boston Phoenix (Peter Keough) review
- ReelTalk (Donald Levit) review
- Hollywood Snitch (Kim Parobek) dvd review
- Film Monthly (Jon Bastian) review
- The Spinning Image (Graeme Clark) review
- Seattle Post-Intelligencer review
- Tiscali UK review
- AfterEllen.com - Lesbian and Bi Women in Entertainment review
- New York Magazine (David Edelstein) review
- Movies 101 (Robert Glatzer) review
- Just Press Play (Arya Ponto) review
- Slate (Dana Stevens) review
- Big Picture Big Sound (Karen Dahlstrom) review
- The Flickering Wall (Jorge Mourinha) review
- Fulvue Drive-in dvd review
- Shadows on the Wall (Rich Cline) review
- ViewLondon (Matthew Turner) review
- The Phantom Tollbooth review
- MovieMaze.de (Dimitrios Athanassiou) review
- Bullz-Eye.com review
- Hollywood and Fine (Marshall Fine) review
- La Presse, Montréal (Marc-André Lussier) review
- Le Soleil, Québec (Normand Provencher) review
-
BBC Five Live (Mark Kermode)
review
- DVD Verdict (Brett Cullum) dvd review
- reVision review
- NPR's Fresh Air (David Edelstein) review
- National Public Radio (Bob Mondello) review
- Cinema Blend review
- Cinema Blend dvd review [Blu-Ray Version]
- New York Observer (Andrew Sarris) review
- Combustible Celluloid (Jeffrey M. Anderson) review
- Movie Gazette review
-
Entertainment Weekly
capsule dvd review
- CineSnob.net (Kiko Martinez) review
- Movie Magazine International review
- Pop Entertainment.com review
- St. Louis Post-Dispatch review
- CinemaZone.dk dvd review
- Austin Chronicle (Kimberley Jones) review
- DVD Savant (Glenn Erickson) dvd review
- Jam! Movies review
- Future Movies (Paul Gallagher) review
- Three Movie Buffs review
- Tail Slate (Douglas Strassler) review
- The Arizona Republic review
- Slate (Dennis Lim) essay ["Could ___ have changed the Prop 8 vote?"]
- Film e Dvd review
- The Age review
- One Guy's Opinion (Frank Swietek) review
- Q Network Film Desk (James Kendrick) review
- Empire Movies (Brendan Cullin) review
- DVD Clinic ("Sturdy") dvd review
- CBC.ca Arts review
- The Movie Boy (Dustin Putman) review
- Digital Spy review
- CNN Showbiz (Tom Charity) review
- Laramie Movie Scope (Patrick Ivers) review
- Laramie Movie Scope (Robert Roten) review
- Cinema Viewfinder (Tony Dayoub) review
- Jigsaw Lounge (Neil Young) review
- DVD Talk (Jason Bailey) review
- CollegeMovieReview.com review
- Isthmus (Kent Williams) review
- HollywoodChicago.com (Adam Fendelman) review
- Nights and Weekends (Kristin Dreyer Kramer) review
- Tony Medley review
- Matt's Movie Reviews (Matthew Pejkovic) review
- Films in Review (Victoria Alexander) review
- A Nutshell Review (Stefan S) review
- RopeofSilicon (Brad Brevet) review
- The Smartest Film Critic in the World (Cole Smithey) capsule review
- Georgia Straight (Ken Eisner) review
- Cinema Signals (Jules Brenner) review
- Cinema 2000 review
- Boxoffice Magazine review
- filmcritic.com (Sean O'Connell) review
- St. Paul Pioneer Press (Chris Hewitt) review
- Movieman's Guide to the Movies (Brad Lowenberg) dvd review
- Houston Chronicle (Amy Biancolli) review
- Phil on Film (Philip Concannon) review
- The Onion A.V. Club (Scott Tobias) review
- The King's Room (Paul Perkins) review
- Salon (Andrew O'Hehir) review
- Window to the Movies (Jeffrey Chen) review
- CompuServe (Harvey S. Karten) review
- Christian Science Monitor (Peter Rainer) review
- Moviepie.com review
- Moviehole review
- Film Blather (Eugene Novikov) review
- Baltimore City Paper (Bret McCabe) review
- Time Out (Melissa Anderson) review
- The Cinema Source review
- The Cinema Source dvd review
- Lobo Howls (Judith Wolfe) review
- Screenjabber review
- Mike D'Angelo <dangelo@panix.com> review
- Bright Lights Film Journal review
-
Cinema Autopsy (Thomas Caldwell)
review
- U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops review
- Edward Copeland on Film (Edward Copeland) review
- New York Post (Lou Lumenick) review
User Reviews
-
May 30, 2011 03:18 am
Amanda said: B
This is a wonderful film. Well written and a brilliant performance from Sean Penn. Gus Van Sant's films always do a fabulous job of bringing you to the characters on an intimate and personal level, and this film excels at this.












Follow us:

Subscribe: